Comparative parental alienation case law & statutes
This page indexes 20 published entries for Comparative in the AntiAlienate open knowledge library: court rulings, statutory provisions and research relevant to parental alienation, custody, contact and the child's best interests. 20 entries carry a formal citation. Last updated 2026-09-25.
Every entry links to its full text and a raw Markdown copy. The library is licensed CC-BY-4.0: reuse it with credit to AntiAlienate (antialienate.com). Machine-readable data: open-data manifest · llms.txt.
Entries for Comparative
CEE cooperation-duty + contact-framework comparative — PL, CZ, HU, RO, SI, HR
PL KRO art. 113 · CZ NOZ §§ 865+891+907 · HU Ptk §§ 4:167+4:178 · RO Codul civil arts. 397+401+487 · SI DZ arts. 141+143 · HR OZ arts. 95+117+121
CEE cooperation-duty + contact-framework comparative — PL, CZ, HU, RO, SI, HR Jurisdiction: Comparative · Coverage: Poland · Czech Republic · Hungary · Romania · Slovenia · Croatia A side-by-side analytical comparison of the six Central and Eastern European cooperation-duty + co…
Updated 2026-06-18 · Read full text · Markdown
Child's voice in custody and contact — age-threshold comparative (IT/DE/AT/NO/SE/IS/ES/UK)
Comparative entry — age thresholds for the child's hearing and weighting of expressed wishes
Child's voice in custody and contact — age-threshold comparative IT/DE/AT/NO/SE/IS/ES/UK Jurisdictions covered: Italy · Germany · Austria · Norway · Sweden · Iceland · Spain · England & Wales A comparative-law map of how each domestic system hears the child and weights the child…
Updated 2026-09-25 · Read full text · Markdown
Commonwealth welfare-checklist comparative — UK, IE, AU, NZ, CA
UK Children Act 1989 s. 1 · IE Guardianship of Infants Act 1964 s. 3 + Part V · AU FLA s. 60CC · NZ COCA ss. 4+5+6 · CA Divorce Act s. 16
Commonwealth welfare-checklist comparative — UK, IE, AU, NZ, CA Jurisdiction: Comparative · Coverage: United Kingdom · Ireland · Australia · New Zealand · Canada A side-by-side analytical comparison of the five Commonwealth welfare-checklist frameworks. All five jurisdictions de…
Updated 2026-06-22 · Read full text · Markdown
Comparative-doctrinal layer — index and navigation
Index entry for the nine-entry comparative-doctrinal layer
Comparative-doctrinal layer — index and navigation The comparative/ pseudo-jurisdiction in this corpus contains a nine-entry comparative-doctrinal layer that maps cross-jurisdictional doctrinal questions in parental alienation litigation. Each entry aggregates the primary-source…
Updated 2026-06-18 · Read full text · Markdown
Cooperation-duty statutory map — Nordic + DACH comparative (Wohlverhaltensgebot family)
Comparative entry — BGB § 1684 (DE) + ABGB § 159 (AT) + Barnelova § 42 (NO) + Föräldrabalken kap 6 § 15 (SE) + Barnalög art. 46 (IS)
Cooperation-duty statutory map — Nordic + DACH comparative Wohlverhaltensgebot family Jurisdictions covered: Germany · Austria · Norway · Sweden · Iceland · plus Denmark, Finland on the descriptive layer A comparative-law map of the affirmative parental cooperation duty often ca…
Updated 2026-06-18 · Read full text · Markdown
Cross-border parental alienation — Hague 1980, Hague 1996, Brussels IIb intersection
Comparative entry — Hague Convention 1980 + Hague Convention 1996 + Brussels IIb Regulation 2019/1111
Cross-border parental alienation — Hague 1980, Hague 1996, Brussels IIb intersection Framework: 1980 Hague Convention on Child Abduction · 1996 Hague Convention on Parental Responsibility · Brussels IIb Regulation EU 2019/1111 · CJEU + HCCH guidance · National implementation A c…
Updated 2026-09-25 · Read full text · Markdown
Domestic violence allegations and parental alienation — bidirectional-risk comparative
Comparative entry — DV-PA bidirectional dynamics across statutory and procedural frameworks
Domestic violence allegations and parental alienation — bidirectional-risk comparative A comparative-law map of the bidirectional dynamic between domestic violence DV protective frameworks and parental alienation PA frameworks. The two operate in genuine tension: DV-protective f…
Updated 2026-06-18 · Read full text · Markdown
East Asian joint-custody reform comparative — JP, KR, TW, CN, HK
JP Civil Code arts. 818+819+824-2 (2024 reform) · KR Civil Act arts. 909+909-2+837+837-2 (2025 reform) · TW Civil Code art. 1055 (1996 reform) · CN Civil Code arts. 1058-1086 (2021 codification) · HK Guardianship of Minors Ordinance art. 3 Cap. 13
East Asian joint-custody reform comparative — JP, KR, TW, CN, HK Jurisdiction: Comparative · Coverage: Japan · South Korea · Taiwan · China · Hong Kong A side-by-side analytical comparison of the five East Asian parental-authority frameworks. The 2024-2025 period saw the most co…
Updated 2026-06-23 · Read full text · Markdown
Enforcement of contact orders — sanctions and compulsion comparative
Comparative entry — enforcement mechanisms for contact orders breached by alienating parent
Enforcement of contact orders — sanctions and compulsion comparative A comparative-law map of how each domestic system enforces contact orders breached by the resident parent . Enforcement is the operational endpoint of PA litigation: a court order requiring the resident parent…
Updated 2026-09-25 · Read full text · Markdown
Expert evidence in PA cases — admissibility + evidential standards comparative
Comparative entry — expert evidence admissibility in PA cases across common-law + civil-law jurisdictions
Expert evidence in PA cases — admissibility + evidential standards comparative A comparative-law map of how each domestic system handles psychological / forensic expert evidence in alienating-conduct cases . This is doctrinally critical because PA litigation typically turns on e…
Updated 2026-06-18 · Read full text · Markdown
Global PA-recognition synthesis — regional + statutory + jurisprudential frameworks
Global synthesis across 7 regional frameworks + 12 express PA-statute jurisdictions + 50+ functional PA-recognition systems
Global PA-recognition synthesis — regional + statutory + jurisprudential frameworks Jurisdiction: Comparative · Coverage: Global synthesis · Scope: 80+ jurisdictions across 7 regional frameworks A synthesizing comparative across the global parental-alienation legal landscape. Th…
Updated 2026-06-23 · Read full text · Markdown
Graduated-remedy ladder for alienating-conduct cases — Italy, Germany, Austria, UK comparative
Comparative entry — CC arts. 333/330/332 (IT) + BGB §§ 1666/1671/1684(3) (DE) + ABGB §§ 181/187(2) (AT) + Children Act 1989 ss. 8/31/91A (UK)
Graduated-remedy ladder for alienating-conduct cases — Italy, Germany, Austria, UK comparative Jurisdictions covered: Italy · Germany · Austria · England & Wales A comparative-law map of the graduated remedy ladder — the structural framework that escalates from intermediate meas…
Updated 2026-06-18 · Read full text · Markdown
Latin American PA-recognition comparative — BR, MX, AR, CO, CL
BR Lei 12.318/2010 · MX CDMX CC art. 323 Septimus · AR CCyC arts. 638-655 · CO Ley 1098/2006 · CL CC + Ley 19.947/2004
Latin American PA-recognition comparative — BR, MX, AR, CO, CL Jurisdiction: Comparative · Coverage: Brazil · Mexico · Argentina · Colombia · Chile A side-by-side analytical comparison of the five major Latin American PA-recognition frameworks. Latin America is the most PA-codif…
Updated 2026-06-18 · Read full text · Markdown
Mediterranean shared-care + alternating-residence comparative — IT, FR, ES, PT, GR
IT CC arts. 337-bis to 337-octies · FR CC arts. 372-373-2-11 · ES CC arts. 92+94+156 · PT CC art. 1906 · GR AK arts. 1510+1513+1520
Mediterranean shared-care + alternating-residence comparative — IT, FR, ES, PT, GR Jurisdiction: Comparative · Coverage: Italy · France · Spain · Portugal · Greece A side-by-side analytical comparison of the five Mediterranean shared-care frameworks. All five jurisdictions have…
Updated 2026-06-22 · Read full text · Markdown
Nordic welfare-paramountcy comparative — SE, NO, DK, FI, IS
SE Föräldrabalken 6 kap. 2a · NO barnelova § 48 · DK Forældreansvarsloven §§ 4+11+21 · FI Lapsenhuoltolaki §§ 1+9+10 · IS barnalög arts. 28+34+46
Nordic welfare-paramountcy comparative — SE, NO, DK, FI, IS Jurisdiction: Comparative · Coverage: Sweden · Norway · Denmark · Finland · Iceland A side-by-side analytical comparison of the five Nordic welfare-paramountcy frameworks — Sweden's Föräldrabalken, Norway's barnelova, D…
Updated 2026-09-25 · Read full text · Markdown
Parental alienation — recognition-status comparative across jurisdictions
Comparative entry — juridical recognition of parental alienation in 20+ jurisdictions
Parental alienation — recognition-status comparative across jurisdictions A comparative-law map of how each domestic system juridically recognises or declines to recognise parental alienation . The recognition question is doctrinally fragmented because PA can be approached three…
Updated 2026-06-18 · Read full text · Markdown
Therapeutic intervention paradigms in PA cases — court-ordered programs comparative
Comparative entry — court-ordered therapeutic intervention across PA-relevant jurisdictions
Therapeutic intervention paradigms in PA cases — court-ordered programs comparative A comparative-law map of how each domestic system orders and supervises therapeutic intervention in alienating-conduct cases. Court-ordered therapy is the principal modality through which the gra…
Updated 2026-06-18 · Read full text · Markdown
Unmarried fathers' acquisition of parental responsibility — cross-jurisdictional comparative
Comparative entry — unmarried fathers' acquisition of PR/custody across UK/DE/IT/FR/US/AU
Unmarried fathers' acquisition of parental responsibility — cross-jurisdictional comparative A comparative-law map of how the principal European and common-law jurisdictions handle acquisition of parental responsibility or its functional equivalent by unmarried fathers . This is…
Updated 2026-06-18 · Read full text · Markdown
US state PA-recognition comparative — CA, TX, NY, FL, TN + 50-state survey
CA Fam Code §§ 3011+3020+3040 · TX Fam Code §§ 153.001+153.134 · NY DRL § 240 + Eschbach + Tropea · FL Stat § 61.13 · TN TCA § 36-6-106 + 36-6-404 · KS KSA § 23-3203 · WA RCW § 26.09.187
US state PA-recognition comparative — CA, TX, NY, FL, TN + 50-state survey Jurisdiction: Comparative · Coverage: United States — 50-state survey with 7 verbatim entries A side-by-side analytical comparison of the US state-level PA-recognition frameworks. The United States operat…
Updated 2026-06-23 · Read full text · Markdown
Welfare-checklist statutory comparative — AT, DE, FR, UK, IE
AT ABGB § 138 · DE BGB § 1697a · FR Code civil art. 373-2-11 · UK Children Act 1989 s. 1(3) · IE Guardianship of Infants Act 1964 Part V
Welfare-checklist statutory comparative — AT, DE, FR, UK, IE Jurisdiction: Comparative · Coverage: Austria · Germany · France · United Kingdom · Ireland A side-by-side analytical comparison of the five core European welfare-paramountcy frameworks that operate as the substantive…
Updated 2026-09-25 · Read full text · Markdown
Other jurisdictions
Colombia · Croatia · All 79 jurisdictions · Knowledge library
Evidence organization resource; not legal advice.