---
title: "US state PA-recognition comparative — CA, TX, NY, FL, TN + 50-state survey"
source: "https://antialienate.com/case-law/comparative/us-state-pa-recognition-comparative"
license: CC-BY-4.0
---

# US state PA-recognition comparative — CA, TX, NY, FL, TN + 50-state survey

Canonical page: https://antialienate.com/case-law/comparative/us-state-pa-recognition-comparative


# US state PA-recognition comparative — CA, TX, NY, FL, TN + 50-state survey

**Jurisdiction:** Comparative · **Coverage:** United States — 50-state survey with 7 verbatim entries

A side-by-side analytical comparison of the US state-level PA-recognition frameworks. The United States operates a *dual federal-state* custody framework: federal law (ICARA, UCCJEA coordination) implements Hague 1980 + interstate coordination; substantive custody law is *50 separate state frameworks*. The state frameworks diverge significantly on PA-recognition, friendly-parent factor codification, and DV-integration design.

## US state-level PA-recognition four-tier classification

### Tier 1 — Express PA-statute language

States with statutory language expressly referencing parental alienation or codifying PA-specific remedies:

| State | Statute | Year | Key feature |
|---|---|---|---|
| **Tennessee** | [TCA § 36-6-106(a)(2)](../united-states/tennessee-tca-36-6-101-best-interests-verbatim.md) — history of denying parenting time in violation of court order | 2018 amendments | Most operationally explicit US friendly-parent factor |
| **Louisiana** | La. C.C. art. 134 — welfare-checklist with alienation-pattern recognition | 2018 amendments | Civil-law tradition with PA-pattern factor |
| **Arizona** | A.R.S. § 25-403 — best-interests factors include parental relationship facilitation | 2013 amendments | PA-pattern recognition via statutory friendly-parent factor |
| **New Jersey** | N.J.S.A. § 9:2-4 — best-interests factors include parental cooperation | Welfare-checklist with cooperation factor | |
| **Florida** | [Fla. Stat. § 61.13(3)](../united-states/florida-statute-61-13-time-sharing-factors.md) — time-sharing factor list with PA-pattern engagement | Time-sharing terminology + extensive factor list | |
| **Idaho** | I.C. § 32-717 — best-interests factors include parental cooperation | Welfare-checklist with cooperation factor | |

### Tier 2 — Express statutory friendly-parent factor

States with express statutory friendly-parent / willingness-to-support-relationship factors but without explicit PA-statute language:

| State | Statute | Provision |
|---|---|---|
| **California** | [Fam. Code § 3011 + § 3020](../united-states/california-family-code-3011-3020-3040-verbatim.md) | § 3011(a)(2) frequent and continuing contact |
| **Texas** | [Fam. Code § 153.134(a)(3)](../united-states/texas-family-code-153-001-153-002-153-134-verbatim.md) | encourage and accept a positive relationship between the child and the other parent |
| **Washington** | [RCW § 26.09.187(3)(a)(vi)](../united-states/washington-rcw-26-09-187-parenting-plan-criteria.md) | nature and stability of the child's relationship with each parent |
| **Kansas** | [KSA § 23-3203(g)](../united-states/ksa-23-3203-kansas-custody-factors.md) | willingness and ability of each parent to respect and appreciate bond between child and other parent |
| **Colorado** | C.R.S. § 14-10-124(1.5)(a)(VI) | ability to encourage the sharing of love, affection, and contact |
| **Michigan** | MCL § 722.23(j) | willingness and ability to facilitate and encourage a close and continuing parent-child relationship |
| **Minnesota** | Minn. Stat. § 518.17(1)(a)(13) | willingness and ability to facilitate a close and continuing relationship |
| **Massachusetts** | M.G.L. c. 208 § 31 — judicial common-law friendly-parent jurisprudence | Functional via case-law |

### Tier 3 — Implicit PA-recognition via welfare-checklist

States with welfare-checklist frameworks where PA-recognition operates through judicial case-law development:

| State | Framework | Authority |
|---|---|---|
| **New York** | [DRL § 240 + Eschbach + Tropea](../united-states/new-york-dr-240-eschbach-tropea-verbatim.md) | Tropea factor (6) thwart-or-accommodate |
| **Illinois** | 750 ILCS 5/602.5 + 5/602.7 | Best-interests factors |
| **Ohio** | R.C. § 3109.04 | Best-interests factors |
| **Pennsylvania** | 23 Pa.C.S. § 5328 | 16-factor best-interests test (factor 8: cooperation) |
| **Georgia** | O.C.G.A. § 19-9-3 | Best-interests factors with friendly-parent consideration |
| **North Carolina** | N.C.G.S. § 50-13.2 | Best-interests standard |
| **Virginia** | Va. Code § 20-124.3 | 10-factor best-interests test |

### Tier 4 — Limited PA-recognition

States where PA-recognition is contested, limited, or developing:

- States with strong DV-presumption frameworks that operationally limit PA-pattern argument
- States where mandatory DV-screening creates structural friction with PA-pattern findings

The Tier 4 framework is sometimes described as the *California paradox* — California has codified DV-presumption ([Fam. Code § 3044](../united-states/california-family-code-3044-domestic-violence-presumption.md)) alongside friendly-parent factor, producing operational tension in PA-pattern cases involving DV-allegations.

## Doctrinal analysis — five key dimensions

### 1. Best-interests-paramountcy formulation

All 50 states + DC + territories operate welfare-paramountcy frameworks, but the formulation strength varies:

| State | Formulation strength | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Texas | *Always primary consideration* | Tex. Fam. Code § 153.002 |
| Tennessee | *Maximum participation possible* | TCA § 36-6-106(a) |
| Wisconsin | *Best interest paramountcy* + maximum participation | Wis. Stat. § 767.41 |
| California | *Health, safety, and welfare* | Fam. Code § 3020 |
| New York | *Best interests of the child* (judicial development) | DRL § 240(1)(a) |

The Texas *always* formulation and Tennessee *maximum participation possible* formulations are doctrinally strongest. The New York framework is statutorily simpler but operationally robust through Court of Appeals jurisprudence.

### 2. Joint custody / joint legal custody default status

US states diverge significantly on joint custody status:

| State | Joint custody status | Default? |
|---|---|---|
| Wisconsin | Presumption of joint legal custody | YES |
| Florida | Presumption of shared parental responsibility | YES |
| Texas | Presumption of joint managing conservatorship | YES |
| Iowa | Presumption of joint physical care | YES |
| Kentucky | Presumption of joint custody and equally shared parenting time (2018 reform) | YES — strongest US presumption |
| California | No statutory presumption; case-by-case | NO |
| New York | Joint legal custody requires affirmative best-interests finding | NO |
| Massachusetts | No statutory presumption | NO |

Kentucky's 2018 reform produced the strongest US shared-parenting presumption — *50/50 equal parenting time* as the structural default subject to rebuttal. The framework is the most explicit US state-level shared-care default.

### 3. DV-screening framework

US states diverge significantly on DV-screening integration with welfare-checklist:

| State | DV-screening framework | PA-impact |
|---|---|---|
| California | Fam. Code § 3044 mandatory rebuttable presumption against custody | Operational tension with friendly-parent factor |
| New York | DRL § 240(1)(a-3) mandatory consideration | Bidirectional |
| Texas | § 153.001(a)(2) safety floor + § 153.005 family-violence factors | Bidirectional |
| Tennessee | § 36-6-106(a)(11) emotional abuse to child or other parent | Bidirectional |
| Florida | § 61.13(3)(m) any other relevant factor + § 61.13(2) parenting plan | Case-by-case |

California's § 3044 *rebuttable presumption* against custody for DV-perpetrators produces the most structurally rigorous DV-screening but also the most operational tension with PA-pattern argument where DV-allegations are contested.

### 4. Sanctions for false abuse allegations

A subset of US states have codified sanctions for false abuse allegations — an operationally critical PA-protective mechanism:

| State | Sanctions framework | Provision |
|---|---|---|
| California | [Fam. Code § 3027.1](../united-states/california-family-code-3027-1-sanctions-false-abuse-accusations.md) — sanctions for false abuse accusations | Court may impose monetary sanctions |
| Tennessee | TCA § 36-6-106(a)(2) — court-order violation history factor | Welfare-checklist consideration |
| Texas | § 153.005(b) — false report consideration | Welfare-checklist consideration |
| Oklahoma | 43 O.S. § 110.1 — sanctions for malicious abuse allegations | Express sanctions framework |

California's § 3027.1 is doctrinally distinctive — the express sanctions provision for false abuse allegations provides structural protection against PA-pattern weaponization of abuse claims.

### 5. Child voice frameworks

US states converge on capacity-based child-voice standards but with significant operational divergence:

| State | Child voice standard | Threshold |
|---|---|---|
| Tennessee | TCA § 36-6-106(a)(13) — reasonable preference age 12+ | Age 12 statutory + younger upon request |
| Texas | Fam. Code § 153.134(a)(6) — child preference age 12+ for primary residence | Age 12 statutory |
| New York | Lincoln hearing + Attorney for the Child framework | Capacity-based |
| California | Fam. Code § 3042 — child 14+ entitled to address court | Age 14 statutory entitlement |
| Florida | § 61.13(3)(i) — reasonable preference based on intelligence, understanding, and experience | Capacity-based |

Tennessee, Texas, and California have express statutory age thresholds. New York and Florida use capacity-based standards. The threshold variation produces operational divergence in PA-pattern cases where the autonomy of the child's stated preferences is contested.

## Cross-cutting US features

### 1. UCCJEA interstate coordination

The Uniform Child Custody Jurisdiction and Enforcement Act (UCCJEA, 1997) is adopted by all 50 states + DC + USVI + PR (Massachusetts retains UCCJA 1968). The UCCJEA establishes:
- **Home state jurisdiction** — where the child has lived 6 consecutive months
- **Emergency jurisdiction** — temporary jurisdiction for protective intervention
- **Simultaneous proceedings** — coordination between competing state courts
- **Modification jurisdiction** — exclusive continuing jurisdiction in original state
- **Enforcement** — full faith and credit for sister-state custody orders

In PA-pattern cases the UCCJEA framework operates structurally:
- Prevents the alienating parent from interstate forum-shopping
- Permits emergency jurisdiction for protective intervention
- Coordinates simultaneous proceedings to prevent conflicting orders

### 2. ICARA Hague 1980 federal implementation

The International Child Abduction Remedies Act (ICARA, 22 U.S.C. §§ 9001-9011) implements Hague 1980 in federal/state courts. Federal district courts have concurrent original jurisdiction with state courts. In PA-pattern cases involving international parental abduction, ICARA provides:
- Return remedy + access remedy
- *Wrongful removal/retention* framework
- *Habitual residence* analysis (post-*Monasky v. Taglieri*, 140 S. Ct. 719 (2020))
- *Article 13(b) grave risk* defense framework

### 3. State-level Family Court infrastructure

US states have varying Family Court infrastructure:

| Infrastructure type | States |
|---|---|
| Dedicated Family Court | New York, Tennessee, Wisconsin, Hawaii, Delaware |
| Family Division of general jurisdiction court | California (Family Division of Superior Court), Texas (Family Law Division of District Court) |
| General jurisdiction handling family matters | Many smaller states |

The infrastructure variation produces operational divergence — dedicated Family Court states (NY, TN, WI, HI, DE) typically have more developed PA-pattern jurisprudence.

### 4. Forensic-evaluator + child-voice infrastructure

US state-level infrastructure for multidisciplinary welfare assessment varies:

| Infrastructure | States with codified framework |
|---|---|
| Court-appointed forensic evaluator | NY (DRL § 240), CA (Fam. Code § 3110), TX (Fam. Code § 107.107) |
| Attorney for the Child / Guardian ad Litem | Most states |
| Child Custody Evaluator certification | CA (AFCC standards), several others |
| AAML Specialist (American Academy of Matrimonial Lawyers) | Across states |

### 5. Therapeutic intervention framework

US states have varying therapeutic intervention frameworks:

| State | Therapeutic intervention provision |
|---|---|
| California | Fam. Code § 3190 — counseling order authority |
| Florida | § 61.13002 — temporary time-sharing during dispute |
| Tennessee | TCA § 36-6-404(a)(3) — minimize exposure to harmful parental conflict |
| Texas | § 153.0071(d) — therapeutic intervention via mediation |
| Massachusetts | M.G.L. c. 208 § 28 — judicial discretion |

The Tennessee § 36-6-404(a)(3) *minimize exposure to harmful parental conflict* codification is the doctrinally distinctive US state-level structural anti-PA codification.

## Operational implications for PA-pattern cases

### Where US state-level framework provides strongest PA-protection

**Tennessee (TCA § 36-6-106(a)(2) + § 36-6-404(a)(3)).** Most operationally explicit US state-level PA-recognition. The combination of express friendly-parent factor with *history of denying parenting time in violation of a court order* codification + parenting-plan-must-minimize-harmful-conflict provision produces structurally rigorous framework.

**Texas (Fam. Code § 153.134(a)(3) + Holley factors).** Strong express friendly-parent factor + Holley v. Adams 9-factor framework. The combination of statutory friendly-parent codification + judicial common-law welfare-checklist provides analytical sophistication.

**Kentucky (KRS § 403.270(2) + 2018 reform).** Strongest US shared-parenting presumption — 50/50 equal parenting time as default subject to rebuttal. Operationally PA-protective because alienating-parent applications must overcome the default.

### Where additional reasoning is required

**California (Fam. Code § 3011 + § 3044).** Strong friendly-parent factor at § 3011 but operational tension with § 3044 DV-presumption. PA-pattern argument must engage carefully with DV-allegation framework.

**New York (DRL § 240 + Eschbach + Tropea).** Strong judicial common-law framework but no express statutory friendly-parent factor. PA-pattern argument operates through Tropea factor (6) thwart-or-accommodate.

## Cross-reference

### US state verbatim entries

- [California — Family Code §§ 3011 + 3020 + 3040](../united-states/california-family-code-3011-3020-3040-verbatim.md)
- [California — Family Code § 3027 child abuse allegations](../united-states/california-family-code-3027-child-abuse-allegations.md)
- [California — Family Code § 3027.1 sanctions false abuse accusations](../united-states/california-family-code-3027-1-sanctions-false-abuse-accusations.md)
- [California — Family Code § 3044 domestic violence presumption](../united-states/california-family-code-3044-domestic-violence-presumption.md)
- [Texas — Family Code §§ 153.001 + 153.002 + 153.134](../united-states/texas-family-code-153-001-153-002-153-134-verbatim.md)
- [New York — DRL § 240 + Eschbach + Tropea](../united-states/new-york-dr-240-eschbach-tropea-verbatim.md)
- [Tennessee — TCA § 36-6-106 + § 36-6-404](../united-states/tennessee-tca-36-6-101-best-interests-verbatim.md)
- [Florida — Statute § 61.13](../united-states/florida-statute-61-13-time-sharing-factors.md)
- [Kansas — KSA § 23-3203](../united-states/ksa-23-3203-kansas-custody-factors.md)
- [Washington — RCW § 26.09.187](../united-states/washington-rcw-26-09-187-parenting-plan-criteria.md)
- [United States — UCCJEA + ICARA + state frameworks overview](../usa/uccjea-icara-state-frameworks-overview.md)
- [United States — Abbott v Abbott (2010)](../united-states/abbott-v-abbott-2010.md)
- [United States — Troxel v Granville (2000)](../united-states/troxel-v-granville-2000.md)

### Comparative cross-references

- [Comparative — Global PA-recognition synthesis](global-pa-recognition-synthesis.md)
- [Comparative — Commonwealth welfare-checklist](commonwealth-welfare-checklist-comparative.md)
- [Comparative — welfare-checklist statutory](welfare-checklist-statutory-comparative.md)
- [Comparative — DV allegations + PA bidirectionality](dv-allegations-pa-bidirectionality-comparative.md)
- [Comparative — child's voice age thresholds](childs-voice-age-thresholds-comparative.md)

## Related entries

- [Comparative — index of the comparative doctrinal layer](index-comparative-doctrinal-layer.md)
- [Comparative — graduated-remedy ladder (IT, DE, AT, UK)](graduated-remedy-ladder-it-de-at-uk.md)
- [Comparative — therapeutic intervention paradigms](therapeutic-intervention-paradigms-comparative.md)
