---
title: "Mediterranean shared-care + alternating-residence comparative — IT, FR, ES, PT, GR"
source: "https://antialienate.com/case-law/comparative/mediterranean-shared-care-comparative"
license: CC-BY-4.0
---

# Mediterranean shared-care + alternating-residence comparative — IT, FR, ES, PT, GR

Canonical page: https://antialienate.com/case-law/comparative/mediterranean-shared-care-comparative


# Mediterranean shared-care + alternating-residence comparative — IT, FR, ES, PT, GR

**Jurisdiction:** Comparative · **Coverage:** Italy · France · Spain · Portugal · Greece

A side-by-side analytical comparison of the five Mediterranean shared-care frameworks. All five jurisdictions have undergone substantial 2005-2021 reform cycles establishing *shared parenting* as the structural starting point, with significant divergence on (i) whether shared residence is a default or an option, (ii) the welfare-protective DV-screening framework, and (iii) the operational PA-recognition layer.

## Comparative table — Mediterranean shared-care provisions

| Jurisdiction | Reform | Joint-exercise default | Shared/alternating residence | Anti-alienation provision |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| **Italy** | Lei 54/2006 (affidamento condiviso) | [CC art. 337-ter](../italy/codice-civile-art-337-ter-provvedimenti-riguardo-ai-figli.md) | Practice-developed; CC art. 337-quater excludes via *affidamento esclusivo* | Implicit via bigenitorialità + DDL Pillon proposals (not enacted) |
| **France** | Loi 2002-305 + Loi 2024-794 | [CC art. 372 + 373-2-9](../france/code-civil-371-1-377-autorite-parentale.md) | *Résidence alternée* (art. 373-2-9 §2) | [Art. 373-2-11 factor 6 *pressions psychologiques*](../france/code-civil-373-2-11-criteres-jaf-verbatim.md) |
| **Spain** | Ley 15/2005 + LO 8/2021 | [CC art. 92 + 156](../spain/codigo-civil-art-92-94-156-custodia-compartida-verbatim.md) | *Custodia compartida* — art. 92(5) by agreement; art. 92(8) exceptional court-ordered | Implicit via TS *SAP* jurisprudence |
| **Portugal** | Lei 61/2008 + Lei 65/2020 | [CC art. 1906(1)](../portugal/codigo-civil-art-1906-responsabilidades-parentais-verbatim.md) | *Residência alternada* — art. 1906(6) court-orderable WITHOUT mutual agreement | Implicit via *disponibilidade para promover relações* factor + *grande proximidade* welfare anchor |
| **Greece** | N. 4800/2021 | [AK art. 1510 + 1513](../greece/astikos-kodikas-1510-1513-1518-synepimeleia-verbatim.md) | *Synepimeleia* + art. 1520 one-third presumption | Express recognition in 2021 prep works + art. 1518(2) *exelifestiko meso* prohibition |

## Three-tier classification by shared-care default strength

### Tier 1 — Express court-orderable shared residence without mutual agreement

**Portugal (CC art. 1906(6) Lei 65/2020).** The doctrinally distinctive Mediterranean framework — the court may order *residência alternada* **independently of mutual agreement** where it corresponds to the superior interest of the child. This is the strongest Mediterranean shared-residence provision because it removes the alienating-parent veto.

**Spain (CC art. 92(8) post LO 8/2021).** *Excepcionalmente* the court may order *custodia compartida* over parental opposition where only this protects the superior interest of the minor — requires Public Prosecutor's favorable report (procedural safeguard). Operationally close to the Portuguese framework but procedurally more rigorous.

### Tier 2 — Express shared residence as priority option

**Greece (AK art. 1513 + 1520 post N.4800/2021).** *Synepimeleia* (joint exercise) is the default post-divorce. Art. 1520 codifies a *one-third minimum communication-time presumption* (rebuttable both directions). The framework establishes a strong shared-care priority without requiring mutual agreement.

**France (CC art. 373-2-9).** *Résidence alternée* is a structural option the JAF may order *à la demande d'un des parents au moins*. The Cour de cassation has confirmed the operational primacy of considering alternating residence as a structural starting point.

### Tier 3 — Shared residence via judicial discretion

**Italy (CC art. 337-ter).** Affidamento condiviso (joint custody) is the post-2006 default, but the *collocazione prevalente* (prevalent placement) is the typical operational form. Shared residence develops through judicial practice, not statutory codification. The DDL Pillon proposals (2018) to make alternating residence a statutory default did not pass.

## Doctrinal analysis — five key dimensions

### 1. Joint-exercise default

All five jurisdictions establish joint exercise as the structural post-divorce default. The formula varies:

| Jurisdiction | Formula | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Italy | *Esercizio congiunto della responsabilità genitoriale* | CC art. 337-ter |
| France | *Exercice en commun de l'autorité parentale* | CC art. 372 |
| Spain | *Patria potestad … se ejercerá conjuntamente* | CC art. 156(1) |
| Portugal | *Exercidas em comum por ambos os progenitores* | CC art. 1906(1) |
| Greece | *Από κοινού και εξίσου* (jointly and equally) | AK art. 1513 |

The Greek *από κοινού και εξίσου* (jointly *and equally*) is doctrinally distinctive — adding the equality dimension to the joint-exercise framing.

### 2. Express friendly-parent/cooperation factor

| Jurisdiction | Codified factor | Source |
|---|---|---|
| France | YES — *aptitude … à respecter les droits de l'autre* + *pressions psychologiques* | CC art. 373-2-11 (3°) + (6°) |
| Portugal | YES — *disponibilidade … para promover relações habituais* | CC art. 1906(5) |
| Greece | YES — *διευκολύνει και προωθεί την επικοινωνία* (facilitate and promote) | AK art. 1520(2) |
| Spain | Indirect — via art. 92(6) *relación que los padres mantengan entre sí* | CC art. 92(6) |
| Italy | Indirect — via art. 337-ter welfare assessment | CC art. 337-ter |

France, Portugal, and Greece have express friendly-parent/cooperation factors. The French art. 373-2-11(6°) *pressions psychologiques* is the doctrinally most direct PA-engagement provision.

### 3. DV-screening interaction with shared-care

| Jurisdiction | Express DV-screening exclusion | Bidirectionality test |
|---|---|---|
| Spain | YES — CC art. 92(7) + 94(4) — *indicios fundados* of DV/gender violence | *Indicios fundados* requires concrete, evidenced indications |
| Italy | Implicit — via welfare assessment | Case-by-case |
| France | Implicit — via art. 373-2-11(6°) + DV-court jurisprudence | Coercive-control framework |
| Portugal | Implicit — via art. 1906(2) reasoned departure | EMAT assessment |
| Greece | Implicit — via art. 1518(2) violence prohibition | Mixed application |

Spain has the most explicit DV-screening framework — but the *indicios fundados* standard has been interpreted by the Tribunal Supremo to require concrete, evidenced indications, preventing PA-weaponization.

### 4. Child's voice standard

| Jurisdiction | Standard | Threshold |
|---|---|---|
| Italy | Capacity-based — *capacità di discernimento* | None |
| France | Capacity-based — *discernement* | None (art. 388-1) |
| Spain | Mandatory above age 12 | Age 12 |
| Portugal | Capacity-based — *suficiente maturidade* | None (RGPTC art. 35) |
| Greece | Capacity-based — *προσωπικότητα* | None (post N.4800/2021) |

Spain retains the age-12 mandatory threshold — the doctrinally distinctive Mediterranean outlier. The other four have converged on capacity-based standards.

### 5. Apex-tier remedy framework

| Jurisdiction | Apex-tier provision | Trigger |
|---|---|---|
| Italy | CC art. 330 *decadenza dalla responsabilità genitoriale* | Welfare-jeopardizing conduct |
| France | CC art. 378-1 *retrait de l'autorité parentale* | *Cause manifestée* of unworthiness |
| Spain | CC art. 92(3) *privación de patria potestad* | *Causa para ello* in proceedings |
| Portugal | CC art. 1915 *inibição do exercício* | Welfare interest |
| Greece | AK arts. 1532-1537 *αφαίρεση γονικής μέριμνας* | Welfare-protective triggers |

All five jurisdictions have apex-tier remedy frameworks accessible in sustained PA-pattern cases — Italy's *decadenza* (art. 330) and France's *retrait* (art. 378-1) are the structurally most developed.

## Operational implications for PA-pattern cases

### Where shared-care framework provides strongest PA-protection

**Portugal (CC art. 1906(6)).** The doctrinally clearest Mediterranean pathway for PA-pattern cases. The court may order alternating residence over alienating-parent opposition. Combined with the express *disponibilidade para promover relações* factor (subsection 5) and the *grande proximidade* welfare anchor (subsection 8), Portugal provides the structurally most PA-protective framework.

**Greece (AK arts. 1510 + 1520).** The post-2021 reform's *synepimeleia* + one-third presumption + *διευκολύνει και προωθεί* daily facilitation duty produces operationally strong PA-protection. The 2021 prep works' express PA-recognition reinforces operational application.

**France (CC art. 373-2-11).** The express *aptitude à respecter les droits de l'autre* (factor 3) + *pressions psychologiques* (factor 6) provide direct doctrinal anchors for PA-pattern findings.

### Where additional reasoning is required

**Spain.** The framework is operationally strong but the LO 8/2021 + LOPIVI 2021 reforms have introduced significant DV-screening complexity. PA-pattern argument must engage carefully with the *indicios fundados* standard to prevent both unjust DV-allegations and unjust PA-denials.

**Italy.** The 2006 affidamento condiviso reform was foundational but operational practice has often defaulted to *collocazione prevalente*. PA-pattern argument is built through the Cassazione jurisprudence on bigenitorialità + art. 337-octies *ascolto* + welfare assessment.

## Cross-cutting Mediterranean features

### 1. Public-prosecutor involvement

All five jurisdictions involve the Public Prosecutor (or equivalent) in family-court proceedings:
- Italy: *Pubblico Ministero* under CPC art. 70
- France: *Ministère public* under CPC art. 425
- Spain: *Ministerio Fiscal* mandatory under CC art. 92(6)
- Portugal: *Ministério Público* under RGPTC art. 17
- Greece: *Εισαγγελέας* (eisaggeleas) where minors involved

Spain's mandatory Public Prosecutor involvement is operationally most rigorous.

### 2. Multidisciplinary assessment frameworks

| Jurisdiction | Assessment body |
|---|---|
| Italy | *CTU* (Consulente Tecnico d'Ufficio) — court-appointed expert |
| France | *Enquête sociale* + *expertise psychologique* |
| Spain | *Equipo Técnico Judicial* (EAT) / *Equipo Psicosocial* |
| Portugal | *EMAT* (Equipa Multidisciplinar de Assessoria Técnica) |
| Greece | *Κοινωνική Έρευνα* (social investigation) |

### 3. 2005-2021 reform cycle

| Jurisdiction | Foundational reform | Recent reform |
|---|---|---|
| Italy | Lei 54/2006 (affidamento condiviso) | Cartabia 2022 (CC art. 473-bis ff procedural) |
| France | Loi 2002-305 (autorité parentale conjointe) | Loi 2024-794 (résidence + coercive control) |
| Spain | Ley 15/2005 (custodia compartida) | LO 8/2021 + Ley 8/2021 (LOPIVI + violence) |
| Portugal | Lei 61/2008 (responsabilidades parentais) | Lei 65/2020 (residência alternada sem acordo) |
| Greece | (no prior major reform) | N. 4800/2021 (full recodification) |

All five jurisdictions completed major reform cycles in the 2005-2021 period. Greece is the most recent (and most ambitious) with the comprehensive N.4800/2021 framework.

### 4. PA-recognition status

| Jurisdiction | PA-recognition |
|---|---|
| Italy | Functional via Cassazione jurisprudence; SAP/PAS controversy limited |
| France | Functional via *contrôle coercitif* + *pressions psychologiques* doctrine |
| Spain | Mixed — TS *SAP* jurisprudence + LO 8/2021 tightening |
| Portugal | Functional via *disponibilidade* + *grande proximidade* |
| Greece | Express via 2021 prep works + N.4800/2021 framework |

Greece has the most express PA-recognition; Spain has the most contested PA-recognition (with the *SAP* jurisprudence in tension with the LO 8/2021 DV-screening reforms).

## Cross-reference

- [Italy — CC arts. 337-bis to 337-octies (affidamento condiviso)](../italy/codice-civile-art-337-bis-octies.md)
- [Italy — CC art. 337-ter provvedimenti riguardo ai figli](../italy/codice-civile-art-337-ter-provvedimenti-riguardo-ai-figli.md)
- [France — CC arts. 371-1 to 377 autorité parentale](../france/code-civil-371-1-377-autorite-parentale.md)
- [France — CC art. 373-2-11 critères du JAF](../france/code-civil-373-2-11-criteres-jaf-verbatim.md)
- [Spain — CC arts. 92+94+156 custodia compartida verbatim](../spain/codigo-civil-art-92-94-156-custodia-compartida-verbatim.md)
- [Portugal — CC art. 1906 responsabilidades parentais verbatim](../portugal/codigo-civil-art-1906-responsabilidades-parentais-verbatim.md)
- [Greece — AK arts. 1510+1513+1520 synepimeleia verbatim](../greece/astikos-kodikas-1510-1513-1518-synepimeleia-verbatim.md)
- [Comparative — welfare-checklist statutory](welfare-checklist-statutory-comparative.md)
- [Comparative — CEE cooperation-duty + contact-framework](cee-cooperation-duty-contact-comparative.md)
- [Comparative — Nordic welfare-paramountcy](nordic-welfare-paramountcy-comparative.md)
- [Comparative — Latin America PA-recognition](latin-america-pa-recognition-comparative.md)
- [Comparative — graduated-remedy ladder (IT, DE, AT, UK)](graduated-remedy-ladder-it-de-at-uk.md)

## Related entries

- [Comparative — index of the comparative doctrinal layer](index-comparative-doctrinal-layer.md)
- [Comparative — PA recognition-status](pa-recognition-status-comparative.md)
- [Comparative — DV allegations + PA bidirectionality](dv-allegations-pa-bidirectionality-comparative.md)
- [Comparative — child's voice age thresholds](childs-voice-age-thresholds-comparative.md)
