---
title: "re-s-2010-ewca-civ-219"
source: "https://antialienate.com/case-law/united-kingdom/re-s-2010-ewca-civ-219"
license: CC-BY-4.0
---

# re-s-2010-ewca-civ-219

Canonical page: https://antialienate.com/case-law/united-kingdom/re-s-2010-ewca-civ-219


# Re S (Transfer of Residence) [2010] EWCA Civ 219

> **TL;DR.** The earliest leading UK Court of Appeal decision endorsing **transfer of residence** as a remedy in intractable contact-dispute / PA-context cases. Predates *Re W (Children)* [2012] EWCA Civ 999 and provides the foundational doctrinal anchor that transfer is a legitimate court tool, not a draconian extreme. Together with Re W, forms the UK appellate doctrine on residence transfer as PA remedy.

**Maintained by Alan Markson · Last reviewed:** 2026-05-17 · **License:** [CC BY 4.0](../../LICENSE)

---

## Citation

> *Re S (Transfer of Residence)* [2010] EWCA Civ 219

## Holding

The Court of Appeal upheld a first-instance transfer of residence in an intractable contact dispute, holding:

1. **Transfer of residence is a legitimate remedy** when conventional measures (contact orders, supervised contact, enforcement) have demonstrably failed
2. **The trial judge has wide discretion** in shaping the remedy to the specific facts
3. **The child's stated preferences** cannot be the sole determinant when alienation pattern is documented
4. **Best interests** under the Children Act 1989 govern; not a presumption against transfer

This was the first major appellate endorsement in England that **the family court has the authority to use residence transfer to remedy entrenched PA** — opening the doctrinal door that *Re W [2012]*, *Re H-N [2021]*, and *Re C [2023]* later refined.

## Significance

Re S is the **doctrinal seed** for the UK PA-remedy framework:

- **2010** Re S — transfer of residence available
- **2012** Re W [2012] EWCA Civ 999 — transfer endorsed in further intractable case; appellate deference confirmed
- **2021** Re H-N [2021] EWCA Civ 448 — dual-frame abuse + alienation analysis
- **2023** Re C [2023] EWHC 345 (Fam) — behavior-frame expert testimony operationalized

Without Re S, the later cases would have lacked the foundational doctrinal underpinning.

## Practical use

Sample UK motion language:

> *Per Re S (Transfer of Residence) [2010] EWCA Civ 219 and Re W (Children) [2012] EWCA Civ 999, this Court has clear appellate authority to consider transfer of residence as a remedy in intractable contact disputes where conventional measures have demonstrably failed over [N] years. The documented pattern of unenforced contact orders, alienating behaviors per Baker's 8 indicators, and the documented developmental cost of continued delay (per Schore 2001, Lombardo 2013) collectively justify the Court considering this remedy. The Applicant respectfully submits the supporting evidence pack for the Court's discretion.*

## The intractable-contact-dispute frame

Re S established that certain custody cases reach a procedural state where:

- Multiple contact orders have been issued + ignored
- Mediation has been attempted + failed
- Supervised contact has been deployed + obstructed
- Financial penalties / unpaid work orders have been issued + ignored
- Reunification therapy has been ordered + sabotaged

In this configuration, **the court is not bound to continue cycling through measures that have demonstrably failed**. Residence transfer becomes a legitimate option.

## How this interacts with the international convergence

UK transfer-of-residence doctrine sits alongside parallel international tools:

| Jurisdiction | Available transfer mechanism |
|---|---|
| UK | Re S 2010 + Re W 2012 (Court of Appeal authority) |
| US | Harman/Lorandos 2020 data: ~40-50% of substantiated PA cases produce custody modification |
| Italy | Civil Code 337-bis et seq. + Cassazione 9691/2022 |
| Belgium | Civil Code Art. 374 amendments + 387ter enforcement |
| Australia | Family Law Act s60CC (post-2024) + U v U principles |
| ECHR | Strand Lobben v Norway 2019 — affirmative reunification duty |

All operate from the shared principle: when the alienator's behavior is structurally incompatible with the child's right to relationship with both parents, residence is an available remedy.

## Citing posts

| # | Post |
|---:|---|
| 17 | https://www.antialienate.com/blog/pa-vs-estrangement-courts |
| 29 | https://www.antialienate.com/blog/emergency-motions-pa |
| 37 | https://www.antialienate.com/blog/when-to-go-to-trial-vs-settle |
| 67 | https://www.antialienate.com/blog/article-8-motion-template-pack |

## Primary source

- BAILII: https://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWCA/Civ/2010/219.html

## Related entries

- [case-law/united-kingdom/re-w-2012-ewca-civ-999.md](./re-w-2012-ewca-civ-999.md)
- [case-law/united-kingdom/re-h-n-2021-ewca-civ-448.md](./re-h-n-2021-ewca-civ-448.md)
- [case-law/united-kingdom/re-c-2023-ewhc-345-fam.md](./re-c-2023-ewhc-345-fam.md)
- [case-law/united-kingdom/re-s-2020-ewca-civ-568.md](./re-s-2020-ewca-civ-568.md)
- [research/harman-lorandos-2020.md](../../research/harman-lorandos-2020.md)

## Disclaimer

Wiki entry, not legal advice.

---

**CC BY 4.0 · [antialienate.com](https://www.antialienate.com)**
















































































































































































































<!-- AA-CITE-START -->

---

## Sources & authoritative references

**Referenced in this page:**

- [Children Act 1989](https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1989/41)

**Topic baseline (independently verifiable):**

- [HUDOC — European Court of Human Rights](https://hudoc.echr.coe.int/)
- [BAILII — UK / Ireland case law](https://www.bailii.org/)
- [CanLII — Canadian case law](https://www.canlii.org/)
- [AustLII — Australian case law](https://www.austlii.edu.au/)
- [Justia — US case law](https://supreme.justia.com/)
- [Cornell LII — US legal research](https://www.law.cornell.edu/)
- [CJEU CURIA — EU Court of Justice](https://curia.europa.eu/)

<!-- AA-CITE-END -->

<!-- AA-CROSSLINK-START -->

---

## Related on antialienate.com

- [How To File Police Report Custody Dispute Belgium](https://www.antialienate.com/blog/how-to-file-police-report-custody-dispute-belgium)
- [When Child Refuses Contact Pace Needs Structure](https://www.antialienate.com/blog/when-child-refuses-contact-pace-needs-structure)
- [When To Fire Your Therapist Custody Dispute](https://www.antialienate.com/blog/when-to-fire-your-therapist-custody-dispute)
- [Why Consistency Beats Intensity Small Contact Often](https://www.antialienate.com/blog/why-consistency-beats-intensity-small-contact-often)
- [Are Fathers Discriminated Against In Family Court](https://www.antialienate.com/blog/are-fathers-discriminated-against-in-family-court)

<!-- AA-CROSSLINK-END -->
